by San Diego, CA – The family of Ronan Kerr, a 4-year-old boy, is suing the City of San Diego following a heartbreaking incident where a large eucalyptus tree branch fell on him while playing at Villa La Jolla Park. The lawsuit alleges negligence by the city and a tree service company responsible for maintaining the park’s trees.
Ronan’s father, Cathal Kerr, was at the park with his two sons when the tragedy occurred on June 29. Despite Cathal’s quick efforts to protect his children, the branch fatally struck Ronan, who later died after a week of hospitalization. The family demands accountability and action to prevent such tragedies in the future.
The Devastating Incident and Immediate Aftermath
The lawsuit details that a 27-foot eucalyptus tree branch fell approximately 60 feet, striking Ronan and injuring Cathal. Cathal managed to push his older son to safety, but Ronan suffered catastrophic injuries, leading to his death on July 6, after seven days at Rady Children’s Hospital.
- Cathal sustained multiple severe injuries including a traumatic brain injury, fractured nose, and facial lacerations.
- His older son witnessed the traumatic event and the subsequent loss of his younger brother.
- The family describes Ronan’s pain and suffering during this period as profound.
“He was literally everything to me. I can’t describe how much I ache and am in pain. I feel like a part of my body has been taken from me and, like, missing a limb,” said Cathal Kerr.
Concerns About Eucalyptus Trees in San Diego Parks
The Kerr family’s attorney, Bibi Fell, explains the inherent dangers of eucalyptus trees, which are not native to California and prone to rot and decay when planted in irrigated parks.
“Eucalyptus trees pose a danger well-known to arborists. This particular tree showed signs of danger that should have been obvious to the City and its contractors,” Fell told on November 13.
Read Also: Miami Beach Yacht Charter Operator Faces Human Trafficking Charges Involving 17-Year-Old Girl
The lawsuit argues that the City and the contracted tree service, Atlas Tree Service, failed to identify and address the risks posed by the tree, which exhibited multiple structural defects easily detectable by a reasonably competent arborist.
Historical Context and Previous Incidents
The suit references nearly 40 prior eucalyptus tree incidents in San Diego, including a tragic case dating back to 1983 where a falling branch from a eucalyptus tree killed a 4-year-old girl near the San Diego Zoo, leading to a previous lawsuit against the city.
Legal Actions and Demands
- The Kerr family filed claims seeking unspecified financial damages for medical expenses, lost earnings, and emotional suffering.
- They demand the city remove or remediate all eucalyptus trees that present an “unacceptable risk” in parks and near schools.
In expressing their grief and motivation to sue, the Kerr family hopes to prevent similar heartbreak for other families.
“This pain is just unbearable, and if we could just save another family from having to go through this, it’ll be worth it,” added Cathal.
What’s Next for San Diego Parks?
The City of San Diego has not commented on the pending litigation. This tragic event has spotlighted the importance of proactive tree maintenance and public safety measures in city parks.
For more details on this developing story, visit the original report on People.com.
Community Reflection and Moving Forward
As the family mourns the loss of their young son and calls for change, the community is reminded of the need for vigilance and preventive care of public spaces.
Key points to remember:
- Children’s safety in parks must be a top priority.
- Eucalyptus trees require careful monitoring due to their known risks.
- City accountability and contractor diligence are crucial for public safety.
What do you think about this tragic incident and the family’s legal action? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
