by FORT COLLINS, Colo. — A former school counselor in Northern Colorado has been arrested and faces multiple felony charges related to the alleged sexual assault of a student. Authorities say there could be additional witnesses or victims, highlighting the seriousness of the case.
Arrest and Charges
Cassadra Poncelow, 40, was arrested on Tuesday by Fort Collins Police, following a tip that she had an inappropriate relationship with a student while employed by the Poudre School District. Police allege the misconduct began when the victim was in high school and involved sexual contact at off-campus locations.
Poncelow is facing multiple charges, including:
- Sexual Assault on a Child by One in a Position of Trust – pattern of abuse with an enhancer of Crime of Violence
- Criminal Attempt to Commit Sexual Exploitation of Children
- Aggravated Sexual Assault on a Client by a Psychotherapist
- Sexual Assault
She was booked into Larimer County Jail on a $500,000 cash-only bond. Court records indicate Poncelow has not yet retained an attorney, and her initial court appearance has not been scheduled.
Alleged Victim’s Account
According to police reports obtained by CBS Colorado, Poncelow first met the alleged victim while navigating high school. The relationship allegedly started in the school counseling office and later continued off campus, where Poncelow is accused of kissing and touching the student in a sexual manner.
The victim told authorities that Poncelow encouraged secrecy by saying, “if you tell anyone, I’ll kill myself.” The alleged assault caused the student to fear for her life.
Poncelow reportedly admitted to the victim that her actions were inappropriate, citing the power imbalance and lack of boundaries, and expressed regret for her conduct following her recent sobriety.
Employment History
Poncelow worked for the Poudre School District from 2007 through 2024, including a role as a counselor at Poudre High School. She also held positions as a part-time behavioral health pathway lead and part-time engagement specialist.
Her LinkedIn profile highlighted her involvement in mentoring programs addressing suicide awareness, stress management, diversity, and sexual assault prevention.
After leaving the school district, Poncelow worked as a ninth-grade success coach at the Center for High School Success, a position that did not involve direct work with students. The organization has since placed her on leave following her arrest.
Read Also: Arizona High School Stabbing: 1 Student Killed, Another Injured in Classroom Attack at Maryvale High
School District Response
A spokesperson for the Poudre School District described the allegations as “deeply troubling” and confirmed the district fully cooperated with law enforcement.
“The safety and well-being of our students are our highest priority,” said Austin Fleskes, public relations coordinator. “We are committed to maintaining a safe, supportive learning environment and responding with transparency and care. Anyone with relevant information is encouraged to contact Fort Collins Police Services.”
Police Statement
Fort Collins Police Lt. Sara Lynd praised the investigative team and emphasized the department’s commitment to supporting the victim:
“We are actively working to support the victim and ensure accountability, knowing that cases like this deeply affect not only those directly involved but the entire community.”
Authorities have indicated the investigation is ongoing, and additional victims or witnesses may come forward as the case progresses.
Community Impact
The allegations have shocked both the school community and the wider Fort Collins area. Many remember Poncelow for her involvement in student mentoring programs, making the charges particularly disturbing. Parents and community members have expressed concern for the safety of students and the need for thorough vetting and monitoring of staff in educational settings.
The Center for High School Success confirmed Poncelow passed all required background checks, stating, “We are shocked and deeply disturbed by the allegations and immediately placed the employee on leave.”
What Happens Next
Poncelow remains in Larimer County Jail on bond while the legal process unfolds. The charges she faces carry severe penalties, including potential imprisonment and long-term implications for her professional licenses and employment. Authorities continue to gather evidence and encourage anyone with information to contact the Fort Collins Police Department.
This case underscores the importance of student safety, staff accountability, and community vigilance in school environments.
If you have information related to this case or want to discuss school safety concerns, comment and share your thoughts at ibwhsmag.com.
